1. You Are At:
  2. Home
  3. Politics News
  4. National News
  5. Narendra Modi-led Gujarat government did not break any rule: Justice MB Shah Commission

Narendra Modi-led Gujarat government did not break any rule: Justice MB Shah Commission

Justice MB Shah Commission has rejected the allegations of corruption, including land allocation to Tata Nano project, against the then Gujarat government headed by Narendra Modi.

India TV Politics Desk, Ahmedabad [Published on:03 Apr 2017, 8:08 AM IST]
Narendra Modi
Narendra Modi

Justice MB Shah Commission, in its report submitted to Gujarat Assembly, has rejected the allegations of corruption, including land allocation to Tata Nano project, against the then Gujarat government headed by Narendra Modi.

Terming the charges “baseless”, the report said that the Commission did not find any substance in these allegations.

The Shah Commission report was tabled in the Gujarat Assembly on March 31.

“If you go by the entire report, you will find that the government had followed all the laws and procedures, particularly the Land Revenue Code, in allotting land to industries. The Commission found no substance in the charges made against the government in that regard,” Justice MB Shah said.

The Commission was formed in 2011 to look into the allegations which mostly pertained to allotment of land for major industrial and infrastructure projects including nine cases related to Tata Nano plant, Adani Group’s Mundra Port and SEZ, and Larsen and Toubro.

In the report, the Commission found no substance in those allegations and termed most of them as “baseless”. 


 

According to Shah, government has not done anything wrong in allotting land to such industries.  

“You can’t just tell the industries to fend for themselves after inviting them here to set up their plants. Tata Nano was also invited here by us. And, land was alloted as per the rules. Same procedures were followed by the past governments too,” said Shah. 

Congress leaders, including Shaktisinh Gohil and Arjun Modhvaida, had submitted a memorandum to the then President in July 2011, listing 17 allegations of corruption against Modi who was at the helm of affairs in Gujarat. 

 

Modi had set up the panel under retired Supreme Court judge M B Shah in August 2011 to inquire into 15 out of 17 allegations, as remaining two were sub-judice.  

According to Shah, those who raised these issues, did not turn up before the Commission to record their statements on many occasions.

“Instead of appearing in person to explain their side, they used to send their lawyer. No one was ready to register their statements before the Commission on affidavit,” said Shah. 

Among these 15 allegations, one was regarding irregularities in “Sujalam Sufalam” canal network project. In his observation in the report, Shah left the matter on government instead of giving a clear verdict.  

“Only the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) or Public Undertakings Committee (PUC) can look into the observations made by the CAG. Commission cannot decide on it. PAC and PUC are the final oa authorities for that,” Shah said.

(With PTI inputs)