Thursday, July 18, 2024
  1. You Are At:
  2. News
  3. Fact Check
  4. FACT CHECK: Old footage from Hurricane Ida incorrectly linked to recent New York floods | DETAILS

FACT CHECK: Old footage from Hurricane Ida incorrectly linked to recent New York floods | DETAILS

India TV's Fact Check team conducted a comprehensive investigation and executed a keyword search on Facebook using the term "New York subway flooded," which directed them to a post by American news outlet ABC News dating back to September 2, 2021.

Edited By: Nitin Kumar @Niitz1 New Delhi Published on: October 04, 2023 14:46 IST
Image Source : INDIA TV Screenshot of old footage from Hurricane Ida about recent New York floods.

A video depicting flooding in the New York subway system has been widely shared online, falsely attributed to the recent flash floods in the city. However, India TV's Fact Check team has determined that this video is from September 2021, captured during Hurricane Ida, a destructive Atlantic hurricane. The video, which has been circulating with the misleading claim that it shows the recent flooding in New York City, is actually a year-old footage from Hurricane Ida's impact. Hurricane Ida caused extensive damage, resulting in 55 direct and 32 indirect fatalities as a tropical cyclone and incurring approximately $75 billion in damages, according to the National Hurricane Center Tropical Cyclone Report.


Image Source : INDIA TVClaim made by Elon Musk

Flash floods struck various parts of New York City on September 29, 2023, prompting the declaration of a state of emergency. Areas such as the Bronx, Brooklyn, and Queens were particularly affected, leading to viral videos depicting submerged cars and waterlogged streets.

India TV conducted a fact-check

To verify the authenticity of the video in question, India TV conducted a fact-check. We conducted a keyword search on Facebook using "New York subway flooded," which led them to a post by American news outlet ABC News from September 2, 2021. This post contained footage that closely resembled the viral video and was captioned, "Water cascades onto a New York City subway train as remnants of Hurricane Ida bring flooding rain to the Northeast."

Comparison of keyframes from the viral video and the one shared by ABC News revealed that they were identical. Additionally, both videos displayed the same train number and station name, "Jefferson Street." The original video was attributed to 'Alex Etling via Storyful.'

Further investigation found that the user, Alex Etling, had indeed shared the video on X on September 2, 2021, with the caption, "Getting a bit of rain in New York City tonight…" Confirmation from Alex Etling in the comments section substantiated that they had captured the video.

Major news outlets, including NBC News and USA Today, also featured this footage during the same time frame, reinforcing its connection to Hurricane Ida in 2021.

Also read | FACT CHECK: IAF refutes false claims of Sikh officers refusing duties due to religious bias | DETAILS

Also read | FACT CHECK | Newspaper's advertisement gaffe: Bellevue Palace featured as an Indian boarding school | Details


Read all the Breaking News Live on and Get Latest English News & Updates from Fact Check