Monday, July 15, 2024
Advertisement
  1. You Are At:
  2. News
  3. India
  4. No danger to free speech, not possible to impose Emergency-like press censorship today: Arun Jaitley

No danger to free speech, not possible to impose Emergency-like press censorship today: Arun Jaitley

Jaitley said that every political viewpoint these days was able to find "some space in some section or the other", and pointed out that the social media permitted individual citizens to express their opinions freely.

Edited by: India TV News Desk New Delhi Updated on: November 16, 2018 22:09 IST
Arun Jaitley

Arun Jaitley

Union Finance Minister Arun Jaitley on Friday rejected the criticism that the Narendra Modi government was curtailing free speech and pointed out that it was not possible to impose Emergency-like restrictions on press freedom in this era as latest technology provides multiple platforms to citizens to express their views.

Jaitley also reminded how Nehru and Indira regimes had sought to put restrictions on the press and free speech. 

"It is fashionable to say these days it's another Emergency. Even if Emergency were ever to be reimposed today, it would collapse for the simple reason that one of the strengths of Emergency was press censorship and technology doesn't permit press censorship," Jaitley said while speaking at an event on the occasion of the National Press Day organised by the Press Council of India (PCI) in New Delhi. 

"Technology does not permit any kind of prior restraint today. You will get access to information through various means that technology provides," he added. 

The finance minister expressed surprise over the criticism by some people who say that free speech was in danger. 

"Well, your free speech can't be in danger if you are criticising seven days a week. You have multiple forums. The technology has made censorship impossible, it has made pressuring impossible. You can pressurise one or two media houses but not thousands," he said. 

Jaitley said that every political viewpoint these days was able to find "some space in some section or the other", and pointed out that the social media permitted individual citizens to express their opinions freely. 

"With these multiple platforms now available nobody can seriously complain that their free speech is in danger," he said. 

The Minister emphasised that the biggest challenge the media faced today was not that of curtailment of free speech but that of retaining its own credibility.

"The biggest challenge today is how the media retains its own credibility so that it continues to become a maker of public opinion," Jaitley said. 

The Minister pointed out that although the Constituent Assembly after an intense debate had kept ‘public order' out of the criterion for putting restrictions on free speech, the first Constitutional Amendment brought by the Jawaharlal Nehru government was to introduce ‘public order' back into the law.

"It also smuggled in another restriction -- a restriction can be imposed if free speech tends to disturb relations with foreign countries. So strictly speaking, an editorial which adversely comments on your approach towards a foreign state, the state can take objection. Thankfully it has not been used so far but it remains the part of law," he said.

"Today, slightest of offence or comment can attract allegation of media or free speech being attacked. In 1952, the then I&B Minister decided that cricket commentary should not be broadcast on All India Radio (AIR). 

"He felt film music was unnecessary in any language and only classical music should be broadcast. There was objection to using Urdu words in Hindi. Therefore from 1952 to 1962 we didn't have any of these," he said.

Jaitley mentioned the ‘price page policy' brought by the government in 1962 under which newspapers had to fix their price depending on the number of pages they had. 

"In 1974 there was a move that size of newspaper should be restricted in national economic interests because newsprint was expensive. Every paper was told certain number of pages it could publish. And if you publish news you could not publish advertisements. But ads keep the news alive by financially supporting the publication. So cutting down advertisement is effectively denial of your right to publish news," the Minister said.

(With PTI inputs)

Advertisement

Read all the Breaking News Live on indiatvnews.com and Get Latest English News & Updates from India

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement