Delhi excise policy news: Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) leaders, some of whom are part of the government, considered the Delhi excise policy as a device to generate illegal funds at the cost of the state exchequer, the Enforcement Directorate (ED) told a local court today (November 30).
It also said that at least 36 accused, including Delhi Deputy Chief Minister Manish Sisodia and a PA of Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal, "destroyed or used" 170 phones in order to conceal evidence of "kickbacks" worth thousand of crores of rupees in the alleged scam.
"The policy was formulated with deliberate loopholes, inbuilt mechanism to facilitate illegal activities and is marred with deliberate inconsistencies which when looked deeply, reflect malafide intentions of the policymakers.
"This policy, though on the face of it, has promising and laudable objectives of stopping cartelisation and encouraging fair trade practices, in reality it promoted cartel formations through back door, awarded exorbitant wholesale (12 per cent) and huge retail (185 per cent) profit margins and incentivised other illegal activities on account of criminal conspiracy of leaders of AAP (Aam Aadmi Party)," it alleged.
The federal probe agency also claimed that the Delhi government "lost revenue of 12 per cent or Rs 581 crore. Only to fill the personal coffers of the leaders of the AAP and overall the total loss of revenue due to alleged irregularities in the policy stood at Rs 2,873 crore (including loss of licence fee)".
The agency made these claims while seeking the remand of Amit Arora, director of liquor company Buddy Retail Pvt Limited, from a local court after his arrest on Tuesday night. He was later sent to the ED custody till December 7 by the court.
"An attempt was also made to see that the evidence pertaining to the commission of this scam running into thousands of crores were either destroyed which would contain valuable digital data and material to prove further kickbacks.
"It is pertinent to note that major evidences with respect to the subject liquor scam were stored in digital formats both in mobile phones and laptops. However, as soon as the scam was unearthed and the case was handed over to investigating agencies, large number of digital devices were found to be destroyed/changed by the persons involved/suspected to be involved in this case," the ED said.
At least 36 accused/suspects involved in the "excise scam" have destroyed/used 170 phones (as per IMEI analysis), it said.
"There is no earthly reason for the suspects to change their mobile phones, specifically the phones that were used during the period of the scam," it said.
The "magnitude" of the destruction is such that most suspects, liquor barons, senior government officials, the excise minister of Delhi (Sisodia) and other suspects have changed their phones multiple times, it said, adding the cost of the phones involved in these instances is about Rs 1.38 crore.
Fortunately, it told the court, the ED has been able to recover 17 out of 170 phones, otherwise the kickbacks would have been much more and involvement of other important persons would have surfaced more clearly.
Excise policy case: Sisodia's aide Dinesh Arora turns approver; says 'ready to make true disclosure'
Delhi excise policy case: Sisodia sought copies of documents from commissioner, say official sources
The ED annexed a report in the remand note saying Sisodia handled four different mobile numbers and their IMEIs changed 14 times between June 6 and October 14 this year. International mobile equipment identity (IMEI) is a unique number that identifies a cellphone. However, dual SIM phones can have two such unique codes.
The ED also listed the cellphone activity of Delhi Transport Minister Kailash Gehlot, saying he handled a single SIM number but his IMEI changed three times. It also furnished the IMEI change activity of other accused involved in the case such as AAP communications in-charge Vijay Nair, liquor businessman Sameer Mahandru (earlier arrested in the case), Amit Arora, Abhishek Boinpally (earlier arrested) and Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal's PA Bibhav Kumar.
The agency also said that a person named Kavitha Kalvakathla used two phones and her IMEI changed 10 times. It, however, did not identify the person concerned. The ED told the court that in the phones recovered by it, data was found to be "deleted/formatted".
"It is in this background and hardship that the ED had to investigate. Despite this, incriminating material has been unearthed by the ED through the arduous process of extraction and examination of numerous devices," the ED said.
The agency alleged that Amit Arora played a "crucial role" in the alleged scam and he has been instrumental in connecting the cartels of liquor manufacturers, wholesalers and retailers to the political leadership and facilitating 6 per cent kickbacks by working closely with Dinesh Arora (another accused whom the CBI has made approver in the case) and Vijay Nair (arrested earlier) who were working "on behalf of AAP leaders."
It alleged that the "political leaders of AAP" received kickbacks at three levels by introducing irregularities in the implementation of the Delhi excise policy, which has now been scrapped.
The ED said Vijay Nair was "not an ordinary worker" of the AAP but a "close associate of Arvind Kejriwal, the CM of Delhi". It said Nair recorded statements with the ED saying he functions from the camp office of Kejriwal and lives in the government bungalow allotted to Gahlot, who "ironically" lives in Najafgarh in southwest Delhi.
(With PTI inputs)